This week an American gentleman in full military uniform and wielding a rifle in a tiny fenced-in compound with a basketball court in the middle of Sinai’s dog teeth mountains threw up a peace sign as we drove past. Some days later, in the middle of the thirsty, flat desert between Taba and Suez, we were met with another lonely compound. Someone had scrawled “bienvenidos!” on a white board and drawn a smiling face.

What I can only imagine are very bored members of the Military and Foreign Observers (MFO) force are deployed in these compounds, part of Sadat’s legacy. Eleven nationalities are involved, including the friendly Columbians and the basketball-playing Americans we saw. Their job is to “supervise the implementation of the security provisions of the Egyptian-Israeli Treaty of Peace and employ best efforts to prevent any violation of its terms.”

Approximately a minute after passing the compounds we would be met with a checkpoint, manned by a couple of bored Egyptian soldiers. To remind us that this is still Egyptian sovereign territory, perhaps.

I was struck by the disconnect between the theoretical threat of mobilisation by the Egyptian army in Sinai – which the MFO are meant to ward off – the massacre going on in Gaza three hours away, and the political emasculation which means that Egypt, the 2nd biggest recipient of US military aid will never meaningfully challenge the 1st biggest recipient – militarily, diplomatically or otherwise – under the current regime. Even when the latter sprays shrapnel all over its neighbour’s side of the border, injuring four people in the process.

There’s something slightly menacing about Sinai, a sort of latent threat. This despite – or perhaps, because of – the beauty of its vast emptiness, its mountains like monsters which seem to move and change shape as they are enveloped in the usurping darkness.

It is the weight of history though, rather than its topography, which makes Sinai so imposing. As we moved through it I wandered whether Israel mapped out the road we used, whether it lay the foundations of the hotels we stayed in, whether Sharon had taken this very same route when he and his troops rolled through the Mitla Pass. In the gruesome Taba (which has a spirit similar to that of a kitchen showroom) we stood and looked at Saudi Arabia, and Jordan, and then stood at the border with Israel looking at their flags flying in the very near distance, and the army posts on the hills above us, and the shocking normality of it all.

A Russian teenager playing pool in a Taba hotel had a T-shirt bearing the inscription ‘Israel’ against a backgrond of brightly-coloured pictures.

A Bedouin man at Saint Catherine told us (as my father and Dr Moftases bounced up Mount Moussa and I ascended in a state somewhere between cardiac arrest and respiratory failure) that business was slow, that he only goes up the mountain once every ten days at the moment. Because of Gaza? Dr Moftases enquired. No, the guide said. Because of the global economic crisis.

Gaza is in such close physical proximity to Egypt and, yet, so removed from it. When the 1st Intifada broke out in 1987 I was a 10 year-old in the north of England. My mother is strongly pro-Palestine, bitterly anti-Israel, and she transmitted that partisanship to me emotionally before the injustice of Israel’s colonisation of Palestine and the atrocities committed in its name became apparent on an intellectual level.

I was shocked – and saddened – when I came to Egypt in 1996 on a visit and discovered that there wasn’t straightforward support for the Palestinian cause. Or even straightforward sympathy. The issue came up amongst a group of AUC student friends of my cousin, and what have now become familiar accusations of Palestinians having ‘willingly sold their own land to the Jews’ were bandied about, accompanied by the usual charge that ‘one cannot trust Palestinians’ because they’re ‘disloyal’. I wondered if I had arrived in the wrong country from the UK, where people didn’t give a toss about Palestine but at least they (mostly) didn’t demonstrate this odd venom.

The schism in public opinion towards Israel’s invasion of Gaza, the reaction to protests, reminded me of this. The Muslim Brotherhood demonstrated both its ability to mobilise large numbers and its capacity to impose strict discipline: demonstrations were segregated according to gender (which might have occurred naturally) and observed a strict policy of No Domestic Issues (which was orchestrated). Chants of ‘down, down Hosny Mubarak’ were quickly replaced with cries of ‘with [our] soul, with [our] blood, we sacrifice ourselves for you, O Palestine‘ initiated by energetic men standing in front of the crowds.

Leftists in these protests were outnumbered by the MB and didn’t stand a chance of getting their voices heard.

The authorities’ policy towards protests steadily became less tolerant during that first week. Seven days later and a terrifying number of police officers, central security forces members and state security investigations officers were deployed in Ramsis outside the train station on a Friday morning. They surrounded the men performing prayers on street corners while passers-by looked on, waiting.

The end of the prayer was like a starter’s pistol. The crowd immediately began chanting and the police responded, forcing them into an alley before pummeling them with batons and picking them out one by one and taking them to police vans.

At another mosque further down the street men shouted zalem [oppressor] at a plain clothed police man chasing a protestor. The police man stopped and began walking towards the group, his fists clenched. He then picked up a wide slab of concrete from the floor, raised it above his head and broke it at their feet, before cursing them and walking off.

I think that if it was possibly diplomatically to do this, Mubarak might do the same thing to his detractors. Except on their heads. Egypt’s role in facilitating/ignoring the deaths of nearly a thousand Palestinians is currently a topic of much discussion. Numerous media articles have presented this a simple case of The People vs. The Regime, which is not strictly accurate.

There do of course exist many, vocal critics of the regime’s ball-less, shameful response to the issue, but equally, many have come out strongly in support of the continued closure of the border crossing and as little involvement as possible with it. Formally, the reasons for this include the heavy loss of Egyptian life for the Palestinian cause over the years. There is also the frying pan and fire theory, according to which if the border was opened thousands of Gaza’s population would come flocking through it and take up residence in northern Sinai. I’m particularly baffled by this: it hasn’t happened in the three decades that Israel has been tormenting Gaza, so why should it happen now?

There has also been a backlash to the backlash against Egypt prompted by protests outside Egyptian embassies demonstrating against Egypt’s policy in general, but its failure to open its border in particular. Funnily enough, many of the people I know who have taken umbrage at the attacks from abroad and are now banging the nationalist tub are the very same individuals who are most critical of the way that domestic issues are handled by the current regime.

Interestingly, after I left the protest on Friday, shortly after I had seen a protestor beaten unconscious by the police, I got into a taxi driven by a man with a huge beard and shaved head. Without any prompting he launched into a monologue about his eight years locked up in an Egyptian prison because of his membership of an Islamic group (“they were the best years of my life”) before he held forth on the uselessness of these protests, suggesting that they do nothing to either influence government policy or help Palestinians.

Per makes an interesting point on his blog, that oppressed working class Egyptians identify with Palestinians not just because of their shared language, culture and religions but also because they share “a common experience of colonialism and dispossession.” Per points to the numerous times he has heard Egyptians say (of the government) “they’re treating us like Israel treat the Palestinians.”

My own feeling is that this tells us more about Egyptians’ relationship with Israel and their own government, than it does about their relationship with Palestinians and Palestine – rather in the way that Germany remained a bogeyman for several generations of British people after the 2nd World War. The attitude lingers on in expressions such as “so and so is a right Nazi”.

That Israel has become a metaphor for oppression explains both the extreme governmental sensitivity surrounding anti-war protests in Egypt (the ever-present threat of protestors who have not received the MB memo vocally making the association between Israeli aggression and domestic repression) and the moral bankruptcy of the current regime in the eyes of many Egyptians. The worst thing about this bankruptcy is that – like everything about this government – it isn’t based on any discernible and defendable policy or moral stand but, rather, is a mixture of unimaginative pragmatism, opportunism, and bending over for the masters.

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

52 Responses to Sa-trap

  1. fully_polynomial says:

    Welcome back!

    Few comments:

    “Funnily enough, many of the people I know who have taken umbrage at the attacks from abroad and are now banging the nationalist tub are the very same individuals who are most critical of the way that domestic issues are handled by the current regime.”

    I don’t find this funny or inconsistent. Being critical of a regime does not equate to being critical of every single decision that regime makes. In this instance, some people felt –rightly or wrongly– that Egypt is doing what is in its best interest.

    The thing that I don’t get though, is the closure of the borders for trade long before the war started, exacerbating the horrible conditions in Gaza. I find this very suspicious on our part.

    “I’m particularly baffled by this: it hasn’t happened in the three decades that Israel has been tormenting Gaza, so why should it happen now?”

    Because Israel wouldn’t like anything more than the Palestinians leaving to go somewhere else, and they (Israel) hugely facilitate this by making Gaza unlivable more and more every day. This latest aggression almost leveled the place. I would imagine there is every incentive for Palestinians to try and relocate across the border. Of course, part of this argument is speculative, but it is not unthinkable. Israel has been vocal at many points in time about its desire to relocate all the Palestinians to Egypt and Jordan.

    Part of your post implies your dad was/is in Egypt? Any stories from this trip to lighten the mood? I loved that story about the Egypt air stewardess serving him Brandy :D

  2. Scarr says:


    Will reply when I am less knackered. Is 2 a.m. here.

  3. Scarr says:

    I think it was the very defensive tone of responses to attacks on Egypt (particularly in response to criticism from outside Egypt) which surprised me…

    I just don’t agree that Palestinians will relocate to Rafah, and stand by the argument that if it was going to happen, it would have already happened…

    Parents’ visit was fun, but largely free of reportable incidents.

  4. betatester5 says:

    anyone defending the mubarak stand during cast lead should be ashamed of him/herself as a human being.

    not only the decison to keep the crossing closed was wrong from a humanitarian view it was also illegal.

    the e media played it well and it wasn't hard. some already with jingoistic ideas found it a good opportunity to blame palestinians or hamas for provoking israel and others bought the pretence of the risk palestinains pose swarming into sinai and drying out sparse resources there..even worse, some said they will never go back and other more delusioned thoughts like it was all a conspiracy from israel to push gazans over to egypt..this is all rubbish.

    while israel may have some intentions for egypt to carry over some of the responsibility for gaza, it only wants that within the gaza zone and not into sinai where they can not have control over them and the responsibility they want the egyptians to share is security-wise not humanitarian as in what you see now..building walls, control over the sea etc but not food or medicine or oil supplies, those must be always under israeli control as much as possible.

    palestinians do not settle in other countries willingly..if that was true, that conflict would have been done with long ago..many people forget that half of the gazans are actually refugees from other parts of palestine and not original inhabitants of gaza.

    according to the geneva convintions, article 48; egypt should have created a 'buffer zone' between gaza and egypt where civilians can flee to. gazans fleeing to the buffer zone will automatically become 'war refugees'.. of course this buffer zone will remain for the duration of the conflict. by creating the zone, egypt would not only be helping out civillans escape a battlefield but will be sending a message to the UN we have war refugees in this area of crisis and the UN will immediately mobilise bodies like the UNHCR and in the gaza case UNRWA as well to cater and support and provide shelter(tents, mattresses, food, medical care and personnel). in other words feeding the palestinians would not have been egyptian responsibility whatsoever and helping them out would not have strained egypt's resources like several idiots in state television claimed. once the war was over, the UNHCR would have safely transported all the refugees back to gaza.

    had this had happened in any other part of the world, the UN would have condemned the neighbouring country for not allowing civilians from a war zone where their life might be endangered but of course since israel was involved, every one turns a blind eye.

    what mubarak did was trap the gazans inside so the israelis can execute their mini-genocide freely and since mubarak was complicit in these war crimes, he is just as liable as whats her name tzibini levni and olemurt and they all should be tried in war tribunal as war criminals.

  5. Sa-trap | Inanities

  6. Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon!

  7. great points altogether, you simply gained a new reader. What would you suggest about your post that you made a few days ago? Any positive?

  8. I respect your piece of work, thankyou for all the good blog posts.

  9. I conceive this web site has got very superb pent content material posts.

  10. you’re really a good webmaster. The web site loading speed is incredible. It seems that you are doing any unique trick. Also, The contents are masterwork. you have done a great job on this topic!

  11. The other day, while I was at work, my sister stole my iphone and tested to see if it can survive a 30 foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My iPad is now broken and she has 83 views. I know this is entirely off topic but I had to share it with someone!

  12. There is apparently a bunch to realize about this. I assume you made various nice points in features also.

  13. You actually make it appear really easy with your presentation but I to find this matter to be really something which I believe I might never understand. It kind of feels too complicated and extremely huge for me. I am having a look ahead to your next post, I will try to get the hold of it!

  14. The schools should also employ means to secure their clients.Sources Drew Agrees To Join Red Sox RealGM WiretapStephen Drew has agreed to a oneyear contract with the Red Sox, sources told ESPN The Magazine’s Buster Olney. Since it has countless participants, it may tremendously benefit your small business. As being a method to qualify, 1 needs to sit for your a+ exams and on passing, is subsequently handed his a+ certification. Silicone will gradually turn the tires brown and then make them crack.
    Cheap Jerseys China

  15. After xie feng: wonder goal to prequel player movement less want to win the ball hard
    adidas zx

  16. It’s a risk repeated throughout Dallas County, from ramshackle bungalows in South Dallas, to half-million-dollar homes in Richardson, to new lofts along the Trinity River.
    giuseppe zanotti shoes

  17. Half-time: tajik free-kick stroke, the green 1-0 down
    lebron soldier

  18. linked says:

    Helpful information. Lucky me I discovered your website unintentionally, and I am surprised why this twist of fate didn’t came about in advance! I bookmarked it.

  19. Not many people are going to like this but it’s true, resumes with black-ethnic names tend to get tossed in the trash a lot and it’s not why you think! I am the first one to admit I toss them in trash, and I will tell you why. It has nothing to do with the race and everything to do with perception. I can think back to black girls and women who had a name like Lisa, Karen, Deborah, Danielle. They were not mean, they didn’t have attitudes, they weren’t scrappy, they were not loud and obnoxious. Now when I think back of all the black girls and women name LaKeisha, Laquanda, Shante; these were the ones who were mean, scrappy, full of attitude and bring back nightmares from my childhood! These were the back women who made my life a living hell, they made everyones life a living hell! These were the loud boisterous in your face full of piss and vinegar that left a sour taste in your mouth! That is why their resumes get tossed in the trash. Still to this day if I call customer service, order from fast food, have an issue in public, see comments on social media, it’s always the ethnic named black women with attitude and drama, it’s a turn off! Many jobs I’ve sat in offices going through resumes with my boss and it’s always the same, these names come through and we both go heck no because we don’t want the attitude queen associated with the name or the tongue clicking, or the horrible grammar also associated with the name! I’ve hired many black women who have been the best employees ever but still to this day I am not giving two thoughts to a resume with an ethnic black name, and now young why! I don’t want the drama associated with the name.
    cartier love bracelet buy online

  20. 2、 但是真正能够接受融资租赁这一形式的并不是很多,本文从技术研发体系的角度分析了日本资源循环型住宅开发项目的背景以及内容,既往关于住宅资源循环利用的研究侧重于对农村生态住宅以及资源循环利用的讨论。是探索”政府主导、社会共建、政府购买服务”模式的有效尝试,其中博士3人、硕士10人。 行业人士说,投产以后的运行问题必然增多。但订单的来源不再集中在高价钻井平台等主流装备。双方均未接听记者电话。不过。

  21. I question the legitimacy of this article, i just cant take it seriously. Very unprofessional.
    montre must de cartier homme

  22. What a web page you have here. You have a actual knack for making a site readable and easy about the eyes. Some sites appear like train wrecks, but not this 1 – it is a joy to learn. Don’t have time to learn all the content pieces right here, I found your web site while searching for something else on Yahoo. But I’ve bookmarked your homepage and can go to it regularly to study what’s new
    arcteryx usa online

  23. 152 . Since it has countless participants, it may tremendously benefit your small business. Let them have information and facts they really want, like howtos or funny blogposts. Also, no. If his return, continue the rally either by spinning the ball with your tacky rubber, or back gently with your button rubber.
    Wholesale Jerseys China

  24. This style of play adds another dimension out of this game, and can be much fun at all levels.260 .A great affiliate marketing tip is to design your site in a way that will get visitors feeling animated and willing to buy products from your web site. When he returns, he will always have an impact back, or yours, or a spin that gives your opponent. To be able to reduce the expense of your event, you should invite much more event management contractors for this job.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys China

  25. sí Uxio, es mi segunda entrada, aunque ahora mi posición es menor porque he aumentado la distancia hasta el stop loss y el 2% no me permite llegar al mismo número de acciones, creo que he de redondear más hacia abajo el número de acciones en próximas operaciones ya que tengo preferencia por entrar dos veces con un stop ajustado frente a una vez con un stop amplio.
    replica orologi pasha cartier

  26. However I do see hybrid sites that are mini-sites or full scale eCommerce sites, with AdSense at the bottom of their pages. This might not be so bad since only 1% – 15% of your site visitors will either buy from you or fill out a form.
    marmot down coats on sale

  27. What about religious freedom of those who consider gay marriage wrong?
    montre cartier pour homme replique


  29. Appreciate writing this. I love the world wide web because you can learn something new every day. I’ll share this with my friends, thank you!
    outlet mammut

  30. Thanks for this info. I’m actually doing actuarial science but I am trying to see which is better compared to IB , when it comes to both hours and general lifestyle outcome
    bangle cartier love fake

  31. Foshan open career – teenagers matching the professional players find tong qu
    stephen curry shoes

  32. What makes girls nuts ought to be the removable gemstones spectacular on the knobs.
    cheap Panerai replica

  33. 1、 使电能节约15%~25%左右,联合空港、邮轮母港、会展等优势平台。对技术很敏感,也是一名婚礼策划人,其中,但大米价格却持续下滑。是不允许重启的,装备制造业主营业务收入1589.海外归国人才也将成为企业需求的新热点。8%。

  34. The reference regarding Alkame Holdings has been an promoted mention for this particular short article.It is now time for the final of the horrible sins. If one percent of your web traffic clicks on an affiliate link, you need a lot of traffic to make money so more traffic equals more money.99, and some of the songs are PSPexclusive, although some are only timed exclusives. Therefore, you have got to be aware of all listings received.
    Cheap NFL Jerseys China

  35. I always spent m褍 half an 液our to read this blog鈥檚 arti喜les everyday along 铡irh a cup of coffee.
    beats by dre

  36. Furthermore, it is essential to make the best selection since your internet variety specifically impacts your website’s uptime.Just leaving your automobile’s glass dirty while detailing your vehicle is amongst the top transgressions.Other necessary products involves bags and kits to carry all this tools about.To add towards the sensuality, the contestants are sometimes clad in skimpy outfits like bikinis.Integrate specialist and fascinating articles in your Facebook or myspace page.
    Cheap China Jerseys

  37. 1、 这一局面亟待改变高档锁具的市场需求也会进一步增加。用能需求越来越大。星巴克中国发布声明称,期待中国的企业家可以讲我国的制造行业推向强国。报道称。 行情起伏稍大,也是真正能够把居民的消费释放出来的房地产及持续健康发展的房地产如:大功率液力变速器、大直径矿井提升机、全地形车、液压挖掘机、超临界萃取装置等工程机械和特色装备。今后我省新型农机装备制造产业要持续、快速发展。

  38. Terror sponsors!!! Go tell GEJ, Modu Sheriff, Asari, Tompolo and others to go to hell. They cannot kill all of us through BH, however much ammunition they give them. The oil you are talking of will dry and be valueless and you will be left with barren, polluted land that cant grow the food you now mercifully receive from the North.
    cartier ronde solo imitation

  39. The wedding decorator will help you to organize your thought wedding. The majority of affiliate companies are not ignorant. If his return, continue the rally either by spinning the ball with your tacky rubber, or back gently with your button rubber.Never settle with your pub and bar business.Get your supporters chatting along with you with each other.
    Wholesale Jerseys

  40. If you want to keep it simpls.”Electrical Safety First has worked with comedian David Walliams to revive the beloved public infoke all good dress shoes, these should be worn at most every other day.

  41. Keeping that vehicle of yours shiny and completely detailed is certainly necessary. As long as you observe the guidelines on the product package, it’s possible to correctly deep clean the car.After you are choosing an affiliate firm to perform with, pick just one who supports their affiliates and gives you assist to provide the product or service. You should try your better to offer new things and different facing people. You may either pay a car detail business in your area to do it or adhere to the simple directions you can find on the back of the auto detailing wax bottle.
    Wholesale NFL Jerseys

  42. If you’d like some special services like wedding designs, venue and dinner, you can discuss with your decorator.Solutions of wedding decoratorsParraz Cly   Submitted 20140107 09:13:55 Do you need Wedding Event Planner Cardiff? You must know the basic decoration ideas as well as services, if you wish to make the good events.Never settle with your pub and bar business. There are actually Prometric and Pearson VUE amenities for using the exams. The actual dancing club will help to entertain your guests in a better way.
    Wholesale Jerseys Cheap

  43. Awsome website! I am loving it!! Will come back again. I am taking your feeds also.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>