Bread & Butter VIII

Ragai (left) with wunderbar lawyer Mohamed Abdel Aziz

Here’s some good news for a change. A copper sentenced to five years after a horrible attack on a man in a police station.

ALEXANDRIA: Relatives of a mentally disabled man who was brutally assaulted in a police station last year were relieved on Saturday after offending police colonel Akram Suleiman was found guilty and slapped a five-year jail sentence.

“This is really great. Thank God. I’m so happy,” Ilhamy Sultan, the brother of Ragai Sultan told Daily News Egypt.

“I really didn’t expect that Suleiman would receive such a heavy sentence … I was confident that he’d be found guilty but thought that he’d be given a two- or three-year sentence at most.

“The court really understood what Ragai went through.”

A juvenile crime squad led by Suleiman arrested Ragai Sultan on the evening of July 22, 2008, as he walked on Alexandria’s Corniche.

His brother eventually found him the next day — after he has filed a missing person report — unconscious in a hospital.

Ragai, who had been dumped at the hospital and registered under the name ‘citizen,’ spent three days in intensive care after suffering a broken rib and shoulder, a fracture in the neck and brain hemorrhage that necessitated surgery.

Suleiman was found guilty of three crimes: misuse of force, possession of an illegal weapon and causing permanent disability.

The first offence carries a maximum sentence of three years while defendants found guilty of the second offence face a maximum of one year’s imprisonment.

The maximum sentence handed down in cases of causing permanent disability is seven years. The sentence is calculated according to the seriousness of the disability caused.

Suleiman’s defense lawyers alleged that Ragai — who is nearly 40 — was targeted by a juvenile crime squad because at the time of his arrest he was accompanied by a teenage girl called Passant, who he planned to engage in sexual relations with for money.

The defense maintained throughout the three-month trial that Ragai’s injuries had been caused by him falling down a flight of stairs while attempting to flee the police.

Forensic doctor Karam Shehata categorically repudiated this defense in October when he told the court that Ragai’s head injuries could only have been caused by being struck with a blunt object.

During Saturday’s court session, Suleiman’s lawyers changed tack and attempted to undermine the credibility of the forensic report. They claimed that Shehata did not examine Ragai and said that the fact that the CT scan carried out on Ragai was not accompanied by a report is irregular.

They also maintained that injuries of the gravity sustained by Ragai could be caused “by someone falling over on a beach while playing tennis”.

Doctors from Al Nadeem Center for the Rehabilitation of the Victims of Violence who attended the trial said that these medical claims were simply “false.”

Mostafa Hussein, a psychiatrist with the Nadeem Center, told Daily News Egypt that CT scans are not usually accompanied by a report printed on the CT film itself, as the defense claimed.

He added that while falls may lead to concussion or a brain hemorrhage, this is only the case where the fall is from “a considerable height” or if the person has a pre-existing malformation in the brain’s blood vessels, “which is not the case with Ragai.”

Two prosecution witnesses, who were held in the Alexandria Security Directorate at the same time as Ragai, appeared during Saturday’s trial, and gave conflicting accounts of what happened.

Both, however, concurred that a junior policeman called Mohamed was responsible for Ragai’s injuries.

Ragai had initially told his brother that the person responsible for his assault was called Mohamed, but changed this account eight months later when, Ilhamy says, his memory returned and he identified Suleiman as his assailant.

Defense lawyers argued that the fact that Ragai changed his account indicates “Akram is an innocent scapegoat.”

Lawyers who had lodged, and won, a claim for LE 10,001 compensation for Ragai’s injuries expressed surprise at Suleiman’s “shambolic” defense team throughout the trial.

During Saturday’s session Suleiman appeared in the dock wearing sunglasses and at points appeared to be crying.

At the conclusion of the defense team’s pleadings, he shouted out from the dock in tears, “Why am I here? Why has nobody listened to me? I’m being tortured in the newspapers and on websites. Why would I hit him? What is there between us that I would hit him?”

Defense lawyer Gamal El-Swede also focused on this angle during his defense pleadings.

He acknowledged that incidents of police violence and brutality do occur, but added, “members of the police only hit people in order to extract confessions.”

While complaints about police brutality are common, few police officers are held to account for such incidents.

Suleiman’s sentencing is roughly the sixth conviction of a police officer for brutality since 2007.

The heaviest sentence was handed down in November 2007 to a police officer and two policemen, each sentenced to seven years imprisonment, after they were found guilty of killing Nasr Ahmed Abdallah.

In a statement issued on Sunday, the Nadeem Center said that Suleiman’s sentence is “one of the heaviest sentences ever handed down by the Egyptian judiciary in a torture case.”

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

15 Responses to Bread & Butter VIII

  1. Wild at Heart says:

    Thank you for the details.

  2. AM says:

    Nice to hear good news every once in a while. Do you think the Interior Ministry is following these cases and prosecuting some, as opposed to their quick dismissal in the past, in order to boost the regime's legitimacy? A new tactic, or just a one-time event?

  3. Scarr says:

    Wild at Heart: Sure.

    AM: Prosecutions and convictions are such a rare thing I don't think we can talk about a change in tactics. And in this case the victim's family was extremely active and not willing to be ignored. Sad to say but also relevant here is the fact that the family is well-off and "respectable" quote unquote, unlike most disenfranchised and poor torture victims who are often simply not equipped to fight back.

  4. Bread & Butter VIII | Inanities
    anfskgnihyz
    nfskgnihyz http://www.g5b02y170k74fepog6s33wcdva0573e6s.org/
    [url=http://www.g5b02y170k74fepog6s33wcdva0573e6s.org/]unfskgnihyz[/url]

  5. 種類の スペースの種類。 Yahooの私に探る最終的にこのにつまずきました。に表明伝えるその私がした この情報を 良い 正確に私は必要なものに出くわしました。 I 最も 確か?| になります行いますない 忘れ俯瞰このウェブサイト と与える​​ 一目 容赦ない基礎。
    ロゼリアーヌ 財布 華やかなバラのデザイン厚手ストール 美しい色使いが人気!フランス製ストール 通販 軽量 フランス製ストール-kym.com.my

  6. ウェブサイト | これをペニングこれを書いに入れて| あなたがしたあなたが持っているの努力をありがとうございました私がしたい。後で|将来的に あなたによってあなたから 同様に。 );今サイト 私の非常に自身の自分自身得るために私を たあなたの創作能力、| 真実では実際には
    ハンドバッグ 小さい 入学式や卒業式、ランチバッグにもおすすめ!桜の花びらミニトートバッグ 無地 桜の花びらデザインが可愛い!ミニトートバッグ 卒業式キルシュ ファスナー付き 軽い かわいい 人気 無地 軽量 財布 ハンドバッグ 人気 レディース レディース ピンク 軽量 おしゃれ かわいい 入学式 軽い ファスナー付き 軽量 通販-kagawa-tokiwa.com

  7. すごい迫力! このテンプレート/テーマを私は本当に掘りです。それは、シンプルでありながら効果的です。多くの時間、それはだ挑戦 ユーザビリティ素晴らしい使い勝手と外観との間の「完璧なバランス」ことを取得します。これで仕事非常に良いを行って、私はあなたがいるあなたがしたあなたがしたこと言わなければなりません。ブログの負荷非常に、高速の私のためインターネットエクスプローラ も。 エクセレントブログ!
    軽量 財布 3000個完売シリーズ!上質牛革のかわいいワンショルダーバッグ。 ココ 革バッグ/ハンドバッグ/ワンショルダーバッグ/ショルダーバッグ/レディース/牛革/マザーズバッグ/あす楽 当店オリジナル本革ショルダーバッグ ミオテゾーロ 通販-www.patrimoniotaguatagua.cl

  8. ねえあり。私はMSNを使用して、あなたのブログを見つけました。よく書かれた記事これは、です。 私がします ことを確認してくださいブックマークにそれをするとリターンをあなたの有用なの続きを読むに。ポストをありがとう。 リターン | 確かに間違いなく | 私は意志私がよ。
    フラットシューズ ラバーパンプス レディース 軽くて持ち運びも水にも強いメッシュパンプス ノーヒールだから旅行にもおすすめ! カジュアルコーデにも大人気の大人パンプス レインシューズメリッルゥ 軽量 ぺたんこ 通販 2016春夏 痛くない 軽量 財布 ぺたんこパンプス 履きやすい&歩きやすいパンプス-kentb.org

  9. I would like to thnkx for the efforts you have put in writing this blog. I am hoping the same high-grade blog post from you in the upcoming as well. In fact your creative writing abilities has inspired me to get my own blog now. Really the blogging is spreading its wings quickly. Your write up is a good example of it.

  10. サイト本当にしたい| | これはされている右ここにあるたいしたいこのトピックを理解する|} {について調べたいと考えています。 あなたが理解して そんなにそのほとんどタフにないこと私は本当に(あなたと議論たい )(笑)へ。 あなたは間違いなく 新しいのスピン対象 となっていたのために| |年間のの年齢のため。 優秀もの、ちょうど優秀!
    おしゃれ ビジネスバッグ 大容量 バックパック 自転車 黒 軽量 バイカラー 財布 リュックサック シンプル ピンク 人気 かわいい 軽い 通勤ビジネスバッグ、通学、マザーズバッグにぴったり!おしゃれなリュックサック あす楽対応 レザー ママバッグ レディース ミレーユ 学生 選べる10色!大人かわいい人気リュック 女子 大きい 通販 通学 バックパック マザーズバッグ-vandiencashmere.com

  11. frappe maker says:

    excellent points altogether, you simply gained a brand new reader. What would you suggest in regards to your post that you made some days ago? Any positive?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>